Dear Shadow Tribe,
 |
| Brown Mountain, NC |
The best-known story attached to them is the lantern of a faithful servant. A planter or hunter went into the mountain and never came back. One of his people took a lantern and went looking. Neither returned. The lights are said to be that lantern still moving across the ridge. Scotty Wiseman turned the tale into the song “The Legend of the Brown Mountain Lights” (also recorded as “Brown Mountain Light”). Listen to it on You Tube.
Other versions talk about Cherokee women searching for warriors lost in an old battle, or a bride who vanished on her wedding night. These stories travel well, but they are obvious later additions. Printed accounts of the lights themselves start showing up around 1912–1913, right as electric lights and railroads were reaching the valleys. Earlier oral claims exist, including a 1771 note from surveyor John William Gerard de Brahm about "vapors" rising from the mountain.
Government people looked at the lights twice in the early years. In 1913 the U.S. Geological Survey sent D.B. Sterrett. He watched from the heights, checked train schedules, and said the lights were locomotive headlights on the Southern Railway lines in the valley. Locals were not convinced.
Other versions talk about Cherokee women searching for warriors lost in an old battle, or a bride who vanished on her wedding night. These stories travel well, but they are obvious later additions. Printed accounts of the lights themselves start showing up around 1912–1913, right as electric lights and railroads were reaching the valleys. Earlier oral claims exist, including a 1771 note from surveyor John William Gerard de Brahm about "vapors" rising from the mountain.
Government people looked at the lights twice in the early years. In 1913 the U.S. Geological Survey sent D.B. Sterrett. He watched from the heights, checked train schedules, and said the lights were locomotive headlights on the Southern Railway lines in the valley. Locals were not convinced.
A big flood in 1916 washed out tracks and stopped trains for weeks; some people said the lights kept appearing anyway, which would be impossible if they were train lights. In 1922 the Survey sent George R. Mansfield. He spent about two weeks on the ground, set up an alidade (a surveying telescope), and took repeated bearings on whatever lights showed. He plotted the results on maps that included the rail lines, roads, and houses.
Mansfield’s conclusion, published as USGS Circular 646 (reprinted in 1971), was straightforward. Of the lights he could measure, roughly 47 percent lined up with automobile headlights, 33 percent with locomotive headlights, 10 percent with stationary lights (houses, etc.), and 10 percent with brush fires. Some appeared to move or flare because of atmospheric refraction in the valley air. Through the telescope many stayed fixed even when the naked eye saw them dance. He did not find evidence for swamp gas, electrical discharge, or anything else exotic as the main cause.
A 1977 experiment by a group of scientists from Oak Ridge National Laboratory aimed a powerful arc light from miles away; observers on the usual overlooks saw it as an orange-red orb sitting above the ridge. Distance, terrain, and night air do a lot of the work.
Those provide possible explanations for most of the classic reports. It does not close the file. Some people still describe lights that move low through the trees or stay on the slope itself rather than hovering above the crest where refracted valley lights would appear.
Mansfield’s conclusion, published as USGS Circular 646 (reprinted in 1971), was straightforward. Of the lights he could measure, roughly 47 percent lined up with automobile headlights, 33 percent with locomotive headlights, 10 percent with stationary lights (houses, etc.), and 10 percent with brush fires. Some appeared to move or flare because of atmospheric refraction in the valley air. Through the telescope many stayed fixed even when the naked eye saw them dance. He did not find evidence for swamp gas, electrical discharge, or anything else exotic as the main cause.
A 1977 experiment by a group of scientists from Oak Ridge National Laboratory aimed a powerful arc light from miles away; observers on the usual overlooks saw it as an orange-red orb sitting above the ridge. Distance, terrain, and night air do a lot of the work.
Those provide possible explanations for most of the classic reports. It does not close the file. Some people still describe lights that move low through the trees or stay on the slope itself rather than hovering above the crest where refracted valley lights would appear.
Modern camera projects out of Appalachian State University have logged thousands of hours and ruled out a lot of ordinary sources; they have also recorded a few brief, unexplained orbs that do not match cars, trains, or campfires. Ball lightning and other atmospheric effects get mentioned as leftovers.
No one has produced a single mechanism that covers every credible report. The lights that match the USGS maps are explained. The ones that do not are still open to debate.
If you want to look for yourself, the practical spots are the Lost Cove overlook on the Blue Ridge Parkway (around milepost 310) and the pull-offs on Highway 181 south of the Parkway. I've looked. So far, I haven't seen anything I couldn't explain.
Clear, moonless nights after full dark give the best chance. Bring a map, know the road and rail corridors, and do not expect a show every time. Most nights you will see ordinary lights doing ordinary things. Some nights you may see something that does not line up. Good luck.
Suggested Reading
If you want to look for yourself, the practical spots are the Lost Cove overlook on the Blue Ridge Parkway (around milepost 310) and the pull-offs on Highway 181 south of the Parkway. I've looked. So far, I haven't seen anything I couldn't explain.
Clear, moonless nights after full dark give the best chance. Bring a map, know the road and rail corridors, and do not expect a show every time. Most nights you will see ordinary lights doing ordinary things. Some nights you may see something that does not line up. Good luck.
Suggested Reading
- The Brown Mountain Lights: History, Science and Human Nature Explain an Appalachian Mystery, by Wade Edward Speer.
The ridge is still there. The reports continue. The explanations that fit the measurements are on the record. The rest is still being watched. Have you seen anything? If so, let us know in the comments.
Between Shadows and Light,
Cade Shadowlight ☠
If this post exposed a dark world to you, consider buying me a coffee so I can keep tracking the shadows they hope stay buried! → https://buymeacoffee.com/cadeshadowlight
As I said, I've looked. I've seen lights. But none I couldn't explain. I live in western NC, so I am sure I'll continue to look. You can be sure I'll report, with pictures, if I ever see anything unexplainable.
ReplyDelete